My boyfriend pointed at the message from a male colleague on my phone. [“Tough luck having to work late this weekend. Your voice sounded like you were coming down with a cold.”] “You’re ending a three-year relationship over a trivial bit of small talk?” he asked, his voice dripping with disbelief. I nodded slowly. “Yes. Exactly over this.” 01 When I brought up the breakup, Bennett Foster remained silent. I couldn’t read a single emotion on his face. He probably thought I was just throwing another one of my “tantrums,” using the word ‘breakup’ as a desperate lever to get him to cuddle me. But none of that mattered anymore. I went back to our bedroom to pack. It didn't take long. I didn’t have much—just enough to fill two suitcases. As I reached for the door handle, I felt a fleeting spark of hesitation. Would he be like he was during our first year? Would he rush over, his eyes red and swollen, grabbing my hand and stumbling through a desperate explanation before we collapsed into a tearful kiss? Or like the second year, when he’d pull me into his chest, even when he was furious, his silent embrace and the gentle pat on my back telling me he still cared? He didn’t move. He stayed on the sofa, mindlessly scrolling through TikTok. Until the moment I walked out that door, he never once looked up. 02 They say breakups are loud, but this one was hauntingly quiet. I realized then that ending it wasn’t just about clearing out a closet. It was about purging the digital ghosts—the Instagram posts, the shared albums, the birthday tags. I’d already archived every photo of Bennett months ago. I knew he didn’t know. Ever since we stopped being long-distance and moved in together, he stopped following my life. He was in it, so he felt he didn’t need to watch it. After one particularly bad fight, I had waved my phone in his face. “The next time you pull this crap, I’m not just archiving our posts. I’m deleting them. Forever.” He had just ruffled my hair with a gentle, patronizing smile and said nothing. He was so certain I would never leave. Even if his face vanished from my feed, he wouldn't panic. He saw my threats as a game. I’d joked once, “Bennett, do you even care? You haven't liked a single post of mine in six months.” He was busy de-shelling prawns for my dinner plate. He frowned slightly. “Harper, I just spent an hour calming you down. I’m exhausted. Can we not do this right now?” I looked at the pile of perfectly cleaned seafood on my plate, a mountain of effort he’d made for me. He hadn't eaten a bite himself. He was always busy ‘doing’ things. Suddenly, I wanted to cry. I couldn’t even remember why we had been in a cold war for a week. I just remembered that I was the one who broke first, the one who apologized and went back to him. He was like he always was—taking me out to a nice dinner, talking about everything and nothing. In our friend group, I was the “dramatic” one, and Bennett was the saint who put up with me. “Infinite tolerance”—that was the label they gave him. Because no matter how many times I mentioned leaving, I knew that if I turned around, he’d be there. But Bennett would never take that extra step forward. He was perfectly self-contained. He never admitted fault. He was immune to my pouting, my logic, and my tears. If I pushed too hard, the silence just lasted longer. Once, we didn't speak for an entire week. Every day, I fought a war inside my head. In the end, I was the one who crawled back. I remember the smell of creamy mushroom pasta wafting from the kitchen. Bennett was in his apron, focused on his knife work, making my favorite meal. But there was no apology. Not a single word. I tugged at his sleeve. “Can you tell me when you’re unhappy? Your silence affects my mood. When you don’t speak, I feel like you don’t need me anymore.” Bennett put down the knife. His hair fell over his eyes, obscuring his expression. His voice was gentle, as always. “Harper, am I good to you?” I nodded. “If you're here because you want to make up, welcome. But if you’re here to prove I was wrong again, maybe you need more time to cool off.” He had his own logic. Why share the bad parts? If you know an emotion is negative, why pass that poison to your partner? At the time, I had looked into his eyes and hugged him tight. “Because that’s what lovers do. They share the weight.” He laughed and pressed my head against his chest, his chin resting on my hair. That day, I posted a quote on my story: “We share the cold fronts, the thunder, the lightning; we share the mist, the rainbows, and the dawn.” But time proved he never intended to share the storm. Every frustration at the office, every stress from the startup—he swallowed it all alone. So when I tried to share my work stress with him, he just frowned. “Harper, we’re adults. We should have the ability to process our own emotions.” In his eyes, my need for emotional support was childish. I thought he was right. I thought I was the immature one. After all, everyone told me how lucky I was. He took his company public in three years. He was handsome, loyal, and had zero vices. He remembered every preference I had. No matter how busy he was, he’d come home and cook a gourmet meal, never letting me lift a finger in the kitchen. 03 The night before the breakup, at 3:00 AM, his phone buzzed. For the first time in three years, I felt a strange impulse. I checked it. “Hey Big Bear, I’m staring at the ceiling. What was the name of that painfully long movie you mentioned? I need something to put me to sleep.” The chat history had been wiped clean. The contact photo was a white kitten. Half of the matching pair was a black cat being tugged by the ear. Classic couple’s avatars. A woman’s intuition is a terrifying thing. I clicked on her profile. It was a diary of her life with her "boyfriend." [“The best part of travel: He carries both massive suitcases, I just carry the aesthetics.”] [“Ugh, he was worried I’d be cold so he made me wait in the car while he ran out to buy me hot roasted nuts.”] There were no faces. No names. No interactions on their public feeds. I scrolled desperately. Finally, I found a photo of a car. I zoomed in until the pixels blurred. In the corner of the frame, the edge of the window revealed the car’s color. White. I let out a breath I didn't know I was holding. Bennett drove a black SUV. I laughed at myself. I was being paranoid. It was probably a wrong number, or an old friend reaching out on a whim. Bennett never hid his phone. If they had been in contact all this time, how would I have missed it? But as I went to exit the app, a watermark on the photo caught my eye. It was a handle for a private Instagram account. I searched it. The handle was: @Is_The_Big_Bear_Groveling_Yet? It was a private account with exactly one follower. My fingers trembled as I requested to follow, then realized I didn't need to. Her "Threads" were public. It was a record of their daily trivia. Even when Bennett was drowning in work before the IPO, he would reply to the songs she shared. [“A bit loud, but I guess it’s what girls your age like.”] During the week of our longest cold war, Bennett had told her: [“Not in a great headspace lately. Might go off the grid for a few days.”] [“Cold war again?”] she asked. Bennett didn't reply. She posted a photo of Bennett napping at a desk. A female finger was poking his nose, squishing it into a "pig snout." The sleeve in the photo belonged to a volunteer shirt for a local animal shelter. I remembered that weekend. Bennett had declined my movie date, saying he had to do volunteer work. He was actually with her. The latest post was from today. She was complaining about a difficult boss. Bennett had replied with paragraphs of advice, comforting her, even criticizing the boss’s behavior. She replied with a string of “LMAOs.” I remembered the time I lost a massive file at work. My boss had screamed at me for twenty minutes, only to realize later that he had taken the file himself and forgotten. He didn't apologize. He told me it was a “learning experience” and that I should always have a backup. I had called Bennett from the stairwell, sobbing. He was silent for a long time before saying in his most 'gentle' voice: “Harper, objectively speaking, he’s right. Everything in life needs a Plan B. Everything needs a backup.” The tears had blurred my vision then. I realized now that Bennett knew exactly how to comfort someone. He knew how to provide emotional value. He just chose not to provide it to me. I didn't sleep that night. The next day, I calmly asked for a breakup. He leaned against the doorframe. The spring air was crisp, the snow was melting, but nothing was as cold as the look in his eyes. “Why?” I showed him the text from my colleague. [“Tough luck having to work late this weekend. Your voice sounded like you were coming down with a cold.”] He curled his lip in a mock smile. “You’re leaving me because of a trivial bit of concern from a stranger? “Harper, does three years of my devotion mean nothing compared to a random text?” I nodded. “Yes. Exactly.” Bennett would never understand. He didn't hear the sickness in my voice that night. A stranger did. 04 We didn’t speak for a whole month. Then, on Valentine’s Day, I got a text from him. [“I found some things you left behind. Come get them if you want them.”] Attached was a photo of a small velvet pouch. Inside was a St. Christopher medal I had bought for him at a cathedral in Europe. Bennett was the man who had everything. Wealthy, successful, elite. I thought the only thing that could move a man like that was pure, unadorned sincerity. I had stood in the rain outside that cathedral, praying for his safety. “If you grant one person your favor, may you spend the rest of your life being generous with them.” The rain had been heavy that day, mirroring the ripples in my heart. When Bennett had walked up with an umbrella, smelling faintly of cherry blossoms, I was sure the universe had heard me. “It’s my birthday and you’re not here? I’ve been looking everywhere for you.” Inside the restaurant, he had tenderly dried my hair. Our friends teased us. “Bennett only blew out the candles so he could wish for you to come back.” He had smiled. “What were you praying for at the church? Health?” I clutched the medal, blushing. “No. I wished for us to be this happy forever.” Bennett’s face had gone cold instantly. “Harper, praying for happiness in a relationship is the beginning of a disaster.” The medal felt like it was burning my palm. I gripped it tight. He was right. Bennett was always logical, always restrained. How could I have been so naive to think a piece of 'sincerity' could bind him? Someone asked, “What’s in the bag, Harper? A gift for Bennett?” I forced a laugh. “Nothing. Just a lucky charm I got for myself.” The bitterness was overwhelming. In Bennett’s vast world, love was just a tiny, manageable province. That night, Bennett had been drinking. He pinned me against the wall, kissing away my tears, murmuring into my neck. “Where’s my gift, Harper?” “I forgot to get one.” “Then you’ll have to pay me back another way.” 05 In the present, my friend Chloe was staring at Bennett’s text. “In my professional dating opinion, this is a total 'come-back-to-me' text. Getting Bennett Foster to reach out first is like getting blood from a stone.” Someone asked, “So what now?” Chloe was fast. She sent my current location to Bennett before I could stop her. “The enemy has moved. We reveal the location and see his next move. Ten to one, he shows up at the door.” I snatched my phone back and blocked his number. “You’re overthinking it,” I said coldly. “But his profile picture is still that photo of your back! And his header is still the sunset you took! You changed yours, but he hasn't.” From the corner of the room, a scoff rang out. “He’s just too lazy to change it. What does that prove? “I could put a photo of Harper in my living room, but does that mean anything? You women love to mistake convenience for commitment.” It was Jax Montgomery. We went to college together. Back then, he was the guy everyone had a crush on. He had a 'thing' with a girl named Seraphina, but it was always messy. I didn't expect this loose cannon to show up tonight. Jax and I had always been at odds in college, but today, for once, we were on the same page. Bennett’s little Instagram girlfriend probably had a partner too. They used matching icons, they stayed in touch, they stayed juuuust on the right side of the line. It was an 'emotional affair' they both enjoyed. The thought made me nauseous. A few rounds of drinks later, someone suggested Truth or Dare. Jax lost. “When was the last time you felt a spark?” someone asked. The bar lights flickered. Jax swirled his bourbon. “Nineteen.” That was freshman year. The year he met Seraphina. According to Bennett, Jax was a classic player—always flirting, never committing. He was the definition of a red flag. I rolled my eyes. Men only realize what they had once it’s gone. A few rounds later, Jax lost again. Chloe smirked. “Is the person who gave you that spark in this room tonight?” Everyone in the room was from our college circle. If he said yes, it was Seraphina. I felt a gaze on me, heavy and fleeting. “Yes,” Jax said. Seraphina walked into the room almost exactly as he said the word. The room erupted in whispers. I felt a headache coming on and stepped out for some air.
? Continue the story here ?? ? Download the "MotoNovel" app ? search for "421729", and watch the full series ✨! #MotoNovel